Home
Playbooks
Employment Agreement Playbook: Employer-Side Review Positions
Employment agreement

Employment Agreement Playbook: Employer-Side Review Positions

By 
Gavel Team
 |  Written for: 
Employer side
 |  Last reviewed: 
November 17, 2026
Run this playbook on your next contract

Gavel Exec reviews and redlines contracts inside Microsoft Word, checked against your own playbook. Start with 25 free queries, no credit card required.

Employment agreement review for the employer tests whether the document keeps employment at will, holds bonus and equity to board discretion, pays severance only against a timely release, defines cause and good reason within the Internal Revenue Code section 409A safe harbor, and uses covenant, invention and arbitration terms the employee's home state will enforce.

Key takeaways

  • Keep employment at will and buy executive protection with severance, which costs less than a fixed term.
  • Build good reason from the conditions, notice limit and cure period in the Treasury's section 409A safe harbor.
  • Pay severance on a fixed day after separation, conditioned on a release, so the employee cannot pick the tax year.
  • California and Minnesota void employee non-competes, Massachusetts requires garden leave or other agreed consideration, and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) rule is gone.
  • Put notice of the whistleblower immunity in the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) in every employee confidentiality clause to preserve DTSA exemplary damages and fees; invention assignments in California, Washington and Illinois need a statutory carve-out notice.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026. This playbook is general information for lawyers, not legal advice for a specific matter. Gavel publishes it and makes Gavel Exec.

Offer letter, employment agreement or executive contract

Most hires sign an at-will offer letter, an invention assignment and confidentiality agreement, and often an arbitration agreement. Executives get a full agreement with severance, cause, good reason and covenants.

Confidentiality basics shared with commercial deals are in the NDA playbook. Other agreement types are on the contract playbooks hub.

Company counsel's positions, with employee and executive flips

The table assumes you act for the employer on its own form or an executive's markup. A reviewer can give the fallback without sign-off; the escalation column goes to the general counsel or the compensation committee.

For a rank-and-file employee, raise an unenforceable non-compete, the invention notice and the arbitration carve-outs. For an executive, flip cause and good reason: willful conduct with a cure right, a sale or new reporting line as good reason, double-trigger acceleration, a mutual release and officer indemnification.

Fourteen terms, from at-will status to choice of law

Every number below is this playbook's suggested starting point. None is a statutory requirement unless the row says so.

IssuePreferred positionAcceptable fallbackEscalate or walk away ifWhy it matters
At-will status and termAt will, no fixed term. No offer letter or policy alters at-will status, and the agreement supersedes earlier offers.Executives: at will, with severance on termination without cause or for good reason.A fixed term with salary owed for the unexpired balance, or company nonrenewal treated as termination without cause.California presumes at-will status only where employment has no specified term (Labor Code 2922).
Base salary and annual bonusTarget as a percentage of salary; committee discretion on amount; paid by March 15 of the next year if still employed.Year-one guaranteed minimum. Prorated bonus on termination without cause.A guaranteed bonus every year, or a bonus owed at any separation.Payment by March 15 fits the section 409A short-term deferral rule.
Equity referencesA recommendation to the board; plan and award agreement control; price at grant-date fair market value.Share count and 4-year vesting with a 1-year cliff stated, still subject to board approval.A promised percentage of fully diluted equity, a price fixed before grant, or single-trigger full acceleration.A below-value option price is deferred compensation under section 409A.
Severance amountExecutives only: 6 months of salary and employer COBRA (Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act) premiums.12 months for the chief executive officer (CEO) and direct reports.Severance on any resignation, or over 2 times salary plus target bonus.Severance is the price of keeping termination at will.
Release conditionGeneral release in the attached form, effective by day 55 after separation, plus continued covenant compliance.Mutual release for senior executives, excluding fraud and covenant breaches.No release condition, or a release form to be agreed at exit.An age claim waiver needs 21 days to consider (45 in a group program) and 7 to revoke (29 U.S.C. 626(f)).
Section 409A payment timingFirst payment on day 60 after separation from service. Each installment a separate payment. Six-month delay for specified employees of public companies.First regular payroll date after day 60.The employee picks the payment year through release timing, or a tax gross-up for section 409A.Noncompliance carries a 20% additional income tax.
CauseFelony, fraud or theft, willful misconduct, material policy violation, covenant breach, or nonperformance 15 days after notice.30-day cure for curable failures. Board vote for the CEO.Cause limited to conviction and willful misconduct, cure for every ground, or a hearing first.Cause decides severance and often equity forfeiture.
Good reasonMaterial pay cut (except across-the-board up to 10%), loss of duties, 50-mile relocation, material breach; 60-day notice, 30-day cure.CEO reporting line added. 90-day notice window. Relocation over 35 miles.Title change or change in control alone, no cure, or good reason judged by the executive.Tracking the Treasury safe harbor treats the resignation as involuntary.
Non-compete12 months, similar roles, states worked, trade secret holders only. None in California or Minnesota.6 months, named competitors, garden leave at 50% of base salary.California or Minnesota non-competes, or Massachusetts ones without notice or garden leave or other agreed consideration.A prevailing California employee recovers attorney's fees in a private action.
Non-solicitation12 months: customers handled in the last 2 years, and employees.Customers with material contact in the last 12 months; general job ads excluded.A customer non-solicit for a California employee.Minnesota and Massachusetts exclude non-solicits from their non-compete statutes.
Invention assignment"Hereby assigns" business-related inventions, with the statutory notice and a prior inventions schedule.License, in place of assignment, for listed prior inventions used in company work.No statutory notice in California, Washington or Illinois, or a promise to assign later.Labor Code 2872 requires written notice when the agreement is made.
Confidentiality and whistleblower noticeNo end date for confidentiality. DTSA notice in the agreement. Agency reports need no notice to the company.Other information protected 5 years after exit. Notice by cross-reference to the whistleblower policy.No immunity notice, or notice to the company before contacting a regulator.Without the notice, no DTSA exemplary damages or attorney fees against that employee.
Arbitration and class waiverIndividual arbitration, class waiver, company pays costs above the court filing fee.Standalone arbitration agreement with a 30-day opt-out.No sexual harassment and assault carve-out, or fees shifted to the employee.Epic Systems upholds individual arbitration; 9 U.S.C. 402 limits it.
Choice of law and forumCompany's home state law and courts, except where the employee's state requires its own law.Law and forum of the state where the employee primarily works.Out-of-state law or forum for a California employee without counsel on those terms.The California employee can void the clause, and a court may award fees (Labor Code 925).

Cause, good reason and the Treasury safe harbor

The section 409A regulations treat a good reason resignation as an involuntary separation when the definition fits 26 C.F.R. 1.409A-1(n)(2)(ii): a material diminution in base pay, authority, the supervisor's authority or budget, a material relocation, or another material breach.

Notice must come within 90 days after the condition arises, the company gets at least 30 days to cure, and the resignation must fall within two years.

Preferred: "Good Reason means any of the following without Executive's written consent: (a) a material reduction in Base Salary, other than a reduction of up to 10% applied to all similarly situated executives; (b) a material diminution in Executive's authority, duties or responsibilities; (c) relocation of Executive's principal workplace by more than 50 miles; or (d) the Company's material breach of this Agreement. Good Reason exists only if Executive gives written notice within 60 days after the condition first occurs, the Company fails to cure within 30 days after that notice, and Executive resigns within 30 days after the cure period ends."
Fallback: "...(e) for the Chief Executive Officer only, a requirement to report to anyone other than the Board... notice within 90 days... relocation by more than 35 miles."

Executive counsel will ask for a sale as a standalone trigger. Offer good reason protection for 12 months after a change in control instead.

Preferred: "Cause means Executive's (a) conviction of, or plea of guilty or no contest to, a felony or a crime involving dishonesty; (b) fraud, embezzlement or theft against the Company; (c) willful misconduct that harms the Company; (d) material violation of a written Company policy; (e) breach of Sections [covenants]; or (f) failure to perform material duties continuing 15 days after written notice. Only clause (f) carries a cure period."

Concede a board vote before a CEO is fired for cause, and refuse a hearing for every ground.

Severance, the release and the payment date

For an employee 40 or older, a waiver of age claims under 29 U.S.C. 626(f) must refer to those claims, exclude claims arising after signing, advise the employee in writing to consult an attorney, allow at least 21 days to consider it (45 in a group program), and allow 7 days to revoke.

Section 409A adds a 20% tax on deferred compensation that breaks its rules, allows payment on separation from service, delays payments to a specified employee of a public company for 6 months, and bars acceleration. Under 26 C.F.R. 1.409A-3(b), a payment window of up to 90 days works only if the employee has no right to designate the taxable year.

A release that can be signed in late December or early January gives the employee that choice. Fix the date. In a group program, 45 plus 7 days leaves 3 days before day 55, so deliver the release at separation.

Preferred: "Severance is conditioned on Executive signing a release substantially in the form of Exhibit B, with any changes required by law, and not revoking it, so that it becomes effective by the 55th day after the Separation Date. The first installment will be paid on the 60th day after the Separation Date and will include any installments otherwise due before then. Each installment is a separate payment for purposes of Section 409A, and any delay required for a specified employee applies."
Fallback: "...under which the Company also releases Executive from claims known to the Board on the Separation Date, other than fraud or breach of Sections [covenants]..."

Executives object to an open release form; attaching it now costs nothing.

Non-competes and non-solicits after the FTC rule

There is no federal ban. The FTC's rule page states that "The Noncompete Rule is not in effect and it is not enforceable" and that a district court stopped enforcement on August 20, 2024. On September 5, 2025 the Commission voted 3-1 to dismiss its appeal and accede to vacatur.

A final rule effective February 12, 2026 removed the rule from 16 C.F.R. part 910. State law decides each covenant.

California. Business and Professions Code section 16600 voids, except as the chapter provides, any contract restraining a person from a lawful trade, profession or business. Section 16600.5 applies "regardless of where and when the contract was signed" and gives employees a private action, with attorney's fees for a prevailing employee.

Section 16601 still lets an owner who sells the goodwill of a business or all of their ownership interest agree not to compete within a specified geographic area, which is how a buyer binds selling founders.

Minnesota. Section 181.988 provides that "Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable." Nondisclosure and nonsolicitation agreements fall outside it. Per Epstein Becker Green, quoting the 2023 session law, it covers agreements entered into on or after July 1, 2023.

Massachusetts. Under G.L. c. 149, section 24L, a non-compete needs a signed writing stating the right to consult counsel, delivery by the earlier of the formal offer or 10 business days before the start date, a restricted period of no more than 12 months, and garden leave of "at least 50 percent of the employee's highest annualized base salary" or other agreed consideration.

It cannot bind employees classified as nonexempt under the Fair Labor Standards Act or employees terminated without cause or laid off. A choice of law clause cannot avoid it for someone who lived or worked in Massachusetts for 30 days before leaving.

Preferred: "For 12 months after employment ends, Employee will not perform services, in a role similar to one Employee held in the last two years of employment, for a business selling [defined competing products] in any state where Employee had responsibilities during that period. This Section does not apply if, when employment ends, Employee primarily resides and works in a state whose law prohibits it."
Fallback: "...for 6 months for a business listed in Exhibit C... The Company will pay 50% of Employee's highest annualized base salary during that period unless it waives this Section within 10 days after separation."

Employees ask for restricted-period pay everywhere. This playbook suggests it for senior roles only, with a company right to waive. In California, protect customer lists through the trade secret clause.

Invention assignment and the state carve-out notice

California Labor Code section 2870 excludes an invention developed entirely on the employee's own time without the employer's equipment, supplies, facilities or trade secret information, unless it relates to the employer's business or anticipated research or results from work for the employer. Section 2872 requires written notice of the exclusion when the agreement is made.

Washington (RCW 49.44.140) and Illinois (765 ILCS 1060/2) follow the same structure with their own notice rules. California and Illinois put the burden of proving the exclusion on the employee. One exhibit can reproduce the statute and hold the prior inventions schedule.

Preferred: "Employee hereby assigns to the Company all right, title and interest in each Invention that Employee conceives, develops or reduces to practice during employment, alone or with others, that relates to the Company's business or actual or demonstrably anticipated research or development, or results from work Employee performs for the Company. Inventions that qualify fully under California Labor Code section 2870 or a comparable state law, summarized in Exhibit D, are excluded."
Fallback: "If Employee uses a prior invention listed in Exhibit E in work for the Company, Employee grants the Company a perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free, worldwide license to use, modify and distribute it as part of that work."

Engineers ask to carve out side projects. Use the schedule and written approval for new outside work.

The DTSA immunity notice and reports to regulators

Under 18 U.S.C. 1833(b), an individual is immune for disclosing a trade secret in confidence to a government official or an attorney solely to report or investigate a suspected violation of law, or in a filing under seal. An employer that omits notice of the immunity from an agreement governing confidential information, entered into or updated after the DTSA's May 11, 2016 enactment, loses exemplary damages and attorney fees under the DTSA against that employee, and contractors and consultants count as employees.

Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Rule 21F-17(a) forbids using a confidentiality agreement to impede anyone from contacting SEC staff about a possible securities violation. Old forms requiring notice before regulator contact are the usual problem.

Preferred: "Nothing in this Agreement limits Employee's right, without notice to the Company, to report a possible violation of law to, file a charge with, or take part in an investigation by any government agency. Under 18 U.S.C. 1833(b), Employee is immune from liability under federal and state trade secret law for a disclosure made in confidence to a federal, state or local government official or an attorney solely to report or investigate a suspected violation of law, or made under seal in a court filing. In a retaliation suit for such a report, Employee may share the trade secret with Employee's attorney and use it in the case if filed under seal and disclosed only under court order."
Fallback: "Employee's reporting rights and the immunity under 18 U.S.C. 1833(b) are described in the Company's Whistleblower Policy, which Employee acknowledges receiving."

Pushback here comes from the business, which wants advance notice of regulator contact. Keep the carve-out unconditional.

Arbitration, class waivers and the employee's home state

In Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis (May 21, 2018), the Supreme Court upheld employment agreements requiring individualized arbitration, concluding that "arbitration agreements like those before us must be enforced as written." Under 9 U.S.C. 402, at the election of the person alleging sexual harassment or sexual assault, no predispute arbitration agreement or joint-action waiver is valid or enforceable for that case, and a court decides whether the section applies.

California Labor Code section 925 bars requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to adjudicate California claims elsewhere, in court or arbitration, or give up California law. The employee can void the clause unless individually represented by counsel in negotiating those terms, so record representation in executive agreements. Minnesota's section 181.988 has a similar rule, limited to claims under that section.

Preferred: "Employee and the Company will resolve any Covered Claim by final and binding arbitration on an individual basis under the Federal Arbitration Act. Neither party may bring or join a class, collective or representative proceeding. The Company will pay all arbitration fees and arbitrator compensation beyond the filing fee Employee would pay in court. This Section excludes claims federal law removes from predispute arbitration, including a sexual harassment or sexual assault dispute Employee elects to bring in court. If a waiver of a representative claim is held unenforceable, that claim proceeds in court and is stayed until the arbitration ends."
Fallback: "Employee may opt out of this Section by written notice to Human Resources within 30 days after signing, with no effect on employment."

Plaintiff counsel will attack the cost terms. Keep the fee sentence; arbitrator fees charged to the employee invite a challenge to the whole clause.

Bonus discretion and equity the board has not granted

State the committee's discretion over any target bonus and pay by March 15; under 26 C.F.R. 1.409A-1(b)(4), payment within the 2 1/2 month period after the vesting year is a short-term deferral. Promise options as a recommendation priced at grant-date fair market value, since a price fixed in the offer letter becomes a discount if the stock rises.

Where the employer or the role changes the answer

Employer or roleWhat changes in the agreementWhy
Early-stage startupEquity is the main term: a recommended share count, grant-date pricing, double-trigger acceleration.26 C.F.R. 1.409A-1(b)(5)(i)(A)(1): the exercise price may never be less than the stock's fair market value.
Private company preparing for a saleSeverance and acceleration can be parachute payments. Add a cutback to the better after-tax result and plan a shareholder vote.At 3 times the base amount or more, a 20% excise tax applies to the excess over the base amount (26 U.S.C. 280G, 4999); private companies can exempt payments by a vote of over 75% of voting power.
Public company executive officersIncentive pay yields to the clawback policy, with no indemnity for amounts recovered.17 C.F.R. 240.10D-1: recovery covers the three completed fiscal years before a required restatement.
Broker-dealer (FINRA member)Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) arbitration governs disputes with associated persons, so the arbitration clause defers to it.FINRA Rule 13200; Rule 13201 removes statutory discrimination claims and some whistleblower claims from required arbitration.
Law firm hiring lawyersNo post-departure non-compete for lawyers beyond retirement benefit conditions.ABA Model Rule 5.6(a), as adopted in the state's conduct rules.
Commissioned sales in CaliforniaThe commission plan must be a written contract stating how commissions are computed and paid, with a signed copy and a signed receipt.Cal. Labor Code 2751; an expired plan is presumed to continue until superseded.

Sources: 26 U.S.C. 280G and 4999, 17 C.F.R. 240.10D-1, FINRA Rules 13200 and 13201, ABA Model Rule 5.6 and Cal. Labor Code 2751.

Employment contract checklist for the company's final draft

  1. Confirm the employee's primary work and residence state.
  2. Confirm the at-will sentence and that no fixed term or guaranteed bonus contradicts it.
  3. Match pay and equity to the approved offer, with bonus discretion, a March 15 payment date and equity as a recommendation.
  4. Read cause and good reason together, with notice and cure windows.
  5. Attach the release form and check the 21 or 45 day and 7 day periods for employees 40 or older.
  6. Confirm a fixed first payment date, separate-payment language and the specified employee delay.
  7. Test each covenant against the employee's state, including Massachusetts notice and garden leave.
  8. Confirm "hereby assigns," the statutory notice exhibit and the prior inventions schedule.
  9. Confirm the DTSA notice or policy cross-reference and an unconditional regulator carve-out.
  10. Check arbitration carve-outs, fees, and whether the employee had counsel.

Drafting errors that cost the employer later

  • Good reason triggered by any title or reporting change, with no notice or cure.
  • Severance payable "promptly after the release becomes effective."
  • A non-compete in the California or Minnesota form, or a Massachusetts non-compete with no garden leave or other agreed consideration.
  • "Agrees to assign" language with no statutory notice exhibit.

Employment agreement review in Word with Gavel Exec

Gavel Exec, AI contract review and drafting software in Microsoft Word, turns your employment checklist, a spreadsheet such as this page's table, or past signed executive agreements (.docx, PDF or .csv) into playbook rules. The Gavel Exec playbooks page explains the setup.

When an executive's lawyer returns a markup, Gavel Exec redlines it in Word as tracked changes ranked by priority, each with its reasoning. Benchmarking in the web app marks every provision on-market, off-market or missing. A seat costs $160 monthly or $1,740 a year, and each user can run 25 free queries before paying, without entering a credit card.

Frequently asked questions

What should an employer check when reviewing an employment agreement?

At-will status, bonus and equity terms, cause and good reason, severance timing and the release, covenants under the employee's state law, statutory notices, and arbitration and choice of law.

Is the FTC non-compete ban in effect?

No. The FTC's rule page says the Noncompete Rule is not in effect and is not enforceable, and a final rule effective February 12, 2026 removed it from the Code of Federal Regulations.

Are non-compete agreements enforceable in California?

Generally not against employees. Business and Professions Code section 16600 voids restraints on a lawful profession, trade or business except as the chapter allows, and section 16600.5 applies regardless of where and when the contract was signed.

What does good reason mean in an executive employment agreement?

It lets an executive resign and collect the severance owed on a termination without cause. The section 409A safe harbor lists material cuts in pay, duties or budget, a material relocation and material breach, with notice within 90 days and a cure period of at least 30 days.

Does an employment agreement need a whistleblower immunity notice?

If the employer wants exemplary damages or attorney fees under the Defend Trade Secrets Act, yes: any agreement governing trade secrets or confidential information must give notice of the 18 U.S.C. 1833(b) immunity or cross-reference a policy that does.

Can an employment agreement require individual arbitration and waive class actions?

Generally yes under Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis. A person alleging sexual harassment or sexual assault can still elect court under 9 U.S.C. 402.

Related reading: how to use AI to review an employment agreement, how employment lawyers are using AI, and the NDA playbook for confidentiality basics.

Try Gavel Exec free

AI contract review and redlining in Microsoft Word, checked against your own playbook, with the reasoning behind each change.

Start a free trial
25 free queries • No credit card required