HotDocs alternatives: 7 document automation tools compared

HotDocs alternatives at a glance

This table compares what each vendor publishes about where its tool runs, how clients answer questions, pricing and trial access.

Why firms look for HotDocs alternatives

HotDocs has been in use for more than 30 years, and Mitratech, which acquired it in June 2024, says it has more than 1 million end users in 60+ countries. It handles large template sets with jurisdiction-specific rules, and Mitratech cites batch processing of 500,000+ documents without manual intervention. Firms comparing alternatives usually weigh three things.

• Price visibility. Mitratech doesn't publish pricing for HotDocs Advance, which it describes as cloud-based, and directs buyers to a demo. Older desktop editions were sold as licenses, so get a current quote before you compare costs.
• Desktop authoring. Templates are built in HotDocs Author, whose current system requirements list Windows 11 and Microsoft Word 2016, 2019, 2021 and 2024. Firms on Macs, or that want to build templates in a browser, need a different setup.
• Scope. HotDocs supports cloud, desktop and hybrid environments, offers HotDocs Advance in cloud and on-premise editions, and connects to other systems through an open API. A small firm automating a few dozen documents may not need that scope.

1. Gavel Workflows: best for client intake and published pricing

Best for: law firms, legal aid organizations and legal teams that produce repeatable documents from client information and want to build and update workflows in the browser.

Gavel Workflows is no-code legal document automation software that runs in the browser, with no download. You build intake forms and questionnaires that clients or staff fill in, automate Word and PDF templates with conditional logic, and generate a complete document set from one set of answers. Litson PLLC used it to cut its time from lead to client by 90%.

• Rebuilding a HotDocs library: Gavel Blueprint generates draft workflows from the fillable PDFs and Word documents you upload, so you start from the documents your templates already produce.
• Client intake: a client-facing portal collects answers and delivers finished documents.
• Integrations: Clio Manage, Docusign, Zapier, DecisionVault and LegalServer.
• Price: from $83 per month, with a 7-day free trial and no credit card. Lite includes 1 builder seat and 10 workflows. Pro, at $290 per month, includes 2 builder and 3 org user seats and adds Docusign, Stripe payments, a custom domain and the legal template library. Annual plans get 2 months free (see all plans).
• Security: data isolation, server encryption and regular third-party penetration testing (security details).

Limits: lower plans cap builder seats and workflows, and the API and single sign-on (SSO) are on the Scale plan, from $417 per month billed annually through sales.

For a detailed side-by-side, see HotDocs vs Gavel Workflows.

2. Knackly: best for small firms converting HotDocs templates

Best for: solo and small firms, such as family law, estate planning and probate practices, that want to bring an existing HotDocs library with them.

Knackly is document automation software built by a team that says it "worked with HotDocs for 20 years prior to starting Knackly." Templates are built in Microsoft Word with the Knackly Word Designer add-in and run from an online workspace, clients "can fill out their own information in guided, step-by-step forms," and one set of answers can produce multiple Word and PDF documents for a case.

• Price: Starter is $250 per month, or $209 per month paid yearly, with 4 users. Done For You, where Knackly handles up to 3 hours of automation work a month (40 hours a year on yearly billing), is $500 per month ($417 paid yearly). Professional, with API access and 12 users, is $1,000 per month ($834 paid yearly).
• HotDocs conversion: Knackly extracts variables from your HotDocs component (.cmp) files, converts the templates and sends them back for you to adjust. Its guide notes that "Computations are not converted."
• Terms and onboarding: all plans are month to month with no setup fees. Starter includes Clio, Zapier and OneDrive integrations and one expert consultation per month, and Knackly automates your first document for you.
• Security: Knackly cites encryption powered by Amazon Web Services (AWS), automated backups and role-based access controls.
• Trial: we found no free trial; Knackly offers a 30-minute live demo.

Limits: converted templates still need manual work on computations and conditional statements, and API access is only on the Professional plan.

See Knackly vs Gavel Workflows.

3. Contract Express: best for large firms on Thomson Reuters

Best for: large law firms and corporate legal departments with complex template sets, especially those that already subscribe to Practical Law.

Contract Express is Thomson Reuters' document automation product, with templates authored in Contract Express Author, "our Microsoft® Word add-in," and guided questionnaires that create "single documents and document suites." With a Practical Law subscription, it includes pre-automated Practical Law templates, and since October 2024 generative AI writes the template code for Contract Express Cloud and HighQ customers.

• Client access: firms can give clients "user-specific dashboards where they can complete an intelligent, online questionnaire," or send the questionnaire as an emailed link.
• Integrations: Docusign for e-signature, iManage and NetDocuments for storage, and HighQ for client collaboration, per Thomson Reuters' law firm brochure.
• Price: not published. Thomson Reuters offers a free demo.

Limits: no published price or self-serve trial, and Practical Law templates need a separate subscription.

See Contract Express vs Gavel Workflows.

4. Clio Draft: best for Clio Manage firms and court forms

Best for: firms on Clio Manage, particularly in practice areas that file a lot of court forms.

Clio Draft is Clio's document automation product, formerly Lawyaw, which Clio acquired in 2021 and renamed in February 2024, per LawNext. Its built-in AI "turns your existing Word documents into reusable templates," client and matter details flow in from Clio Manage, and its library includes "thousands of official state, county, and federal immigration forms" that autofill.

• Client intake: a shareable link lets clients complete a questionnaire on any device, and you save their responses to the matter.
• Where it runs: in the browser, with a template builder add-in for desktop Microsoft Word on Windows and Mac (Office 2016 or later).
• Price: not published. Clio says to book a demo for pricing and offers savings when you bundle Clio Draft with other Clio products.
• Security: encrypted storage, automatic backups and two-factor authentication.

Limits: no published price, the template builder add-in works only in desktop Word, and the product is built around Clio Manage as the source of client and matter details.

See Clio Draft vs Gavel Workflows.

5. MyCase: best for automation inside practice management

Best for: small firms that want document automation, client intake and billing in one practice management system.

MyCase is legal practice management software with built-in document automation that lets you "turn Microsoft Word docs into smart, reusable templates" and auto-fill them with data you've already collected. MyCase acquired Woodpecker, a document automation tool for solo and small firms, in 2021 (per LawNext), and woodpeckerweb.com now redirects to MyCase's document automation page.

• Price: the Pro plan, $100 per user per month billed yearly ($120 monthly), includes Word-based document generation. The Advanced plan, $130 per user per month billed yearly ($150 monthly), adds Advanced Document Automation.
• Trial: 10 days, no credit card.
• Client intake: "dynamic, customizable online forms" on the Pro and Advanced plans.

Limits: document automation comes with a per-user practice management subscription, so firms that only want automation pay for the full system.

See MyCase vs Gavel Workflows.

6. Docassemble: best for teams with developers and their own servers

Best for: legal teams with developer support that want full control over interviews and hosting, with no license fee.

Docassemble is "a free, open-source expert system for guided interviews and document assembly," released under the MIT License. Developers write interviews in YAML, a plain-text format, with logic in Python, and end users run them in a mobile-friendly web interface that produces PDF, Rich Text Format or Word (.docx) documents.

• Hosting: you run it yourself. The docs strongly recommend installing with Docker on a machine with at least 4 gigabytes of memory, and suggest an Amazon Web Services virtual machine for production.
• Capabilities: touchscreen signatures, interviews in multiple languages, multiuser applications and an API.
• Security: server-side encryption, two-factor authentication and document redaction.

Limits: interviews are written as code and you maintain the server, so plan for developer time to build, host and update them.

7. WealthCounsel: best for estate planning and elder law attorneys

Best for: estate planning, elder law and business law attorneys who want interactive estate planning templates with membership support.

WealthCounsel is a membership-based drafting platform that has served estate planning and elder law attorneys "for over twenty-five years." Its flagship software, Wealth Docx, runs in the cloud and builds estate plans through dynamic guided questions; Wealth Docx Core covers wills, living trusts, client letters and trust protector documents, and Wealth Docx Complete extends to more complex planning.

• Price: membership pricing is "based on the number of users in your firm" and the products you choose, quoted after a demo or consultation.
• Memberships: Essential includes Wealth Docx Core. Elite includes Wealth Docx Complete, Elder Docx, Business Docx, Wealth Tracx and Gun Docx, and WealthCounsel + LEAP adds LEAP practice management.
• Client intake: a secure online form with document attachments and a progress dashboard, included in the Elite, Trusts & Estates Professional and Elder Law Professional memberships.

Limits: the software covers estate planning, elder law, business law and trust administration, so firms with other practice areas need another tool, and we found no published price or free trial.

See WealthCounsel vs Gavel Workflows.

How to choose a HotDocs alternative

1. Inventory your templates and logic. Count your templates, flag the ones that rely on computations, repeated dialogs or answers shared across templates, and decide whether to rebuild the whole library or start with the documents you use most.
2. Decide who will build and maintain templates. The options range from Word-based authoring (Contract Express, Knackly) and a browser-based builder (Gavel Workflows) to a done-for-you service (Knackly's Done For You plan) and developer-written code (Docassemble).
3. Decide who answers the questions. If clients will fill in questionnaires themselves, test the client experience on a phone and check that answers land in the right documents.
4. Check your integrations. Clio Draft and MyCase sit inside their practice management suites, Gavel Workflows and Knackly connect to Clio, and Contract Express connects to iManage, NetDocuments and HighQ.
5. Rebuild one hard template during a trial. Gavel Workflows' 7-day trial and MyCase's 10-day trial let you start this week, and Docassemble is free to install. Pick a template with real conditional logic and compare each tool's output with a document you've already sent to a client.

Switching from HotDocs: what to bring with you

• The Word and PDF source documents behind each template. Gavel Blueprint generates draft workflows from the fillable PDFs and Word documents you upload.
• Your HotDocs component (.cmp) files and a list of variables, computations and dialogs. Knackly's conversion process reads component files, and any builder needs this map of your logic.
• Sample answer sets and finished documents for each template, to check the new tool's output against.
• A list of the systems your current setup connects to, such as practice management, document management and e-signature.

More comparisons: the best document automation software, legal document assembly software, Formstack vs Gavel Workflows, Bryter vs Gavel Workflows and all Gavel comparisons.